South Australia Logo Government of SA - Department of Planning, Transport and Infrastructure Logo Government of South Australia Website Department of Planning, Transport and Infrastructure Home Page Government of South Australia Website

Drownings off Stansbury prompt life jackets recommendation

20 Sep 2013

The drowning deaths of two fishermen have prompted the Deputy Coroner to recommend crew aboard commercial fishing boats wear life jackets (Personal Flotation Devices) which can inflate automatically, reports the ABC.

Adam Nicolai and Justin Hellyer died when a fishing boat sank off Stansbury on Yorke Peninsula in September 2008.
The men had been fishing with their friend and skipper of the boat, Andrew Pisani, when two big waves swamped the vessel during a squall.

The court was told the men were not wearing life jackets and all three tried to swim to safety but only Mr Pisani survived.
Deputy Coroner Anthony Schapel said the boat was unregistered and would not have been regarded as seaworthy for the conditions.

"I have accepted Mr Pisani's evidence that the effect of the two large waves was so swift and catastrophic that there was simply no time for any person on board to don PFDs (personal flotation devices) or to secure the buoyancy rings," he said.

"Nevertheless it is hard to disagree with the conclusion of the Industrial Court that there had been a foolhardy and reckless approach to the wearing of life jackets at night in offshore waters in a small vessel that was prone to sinking if swamped.

"As a matter of common sense, the wearing of PFDs would significantly have increased the possibility of both men surviving. Without them they had little chance of survival once a decision had been made not to try to make shore with Mr Pisani."

The coroner recommended the Transport Minister make it a legal requirement for self-inflating flotation devices to be worn at all times by crews on commercial boats.

Mr Pisani's company previously was fined in the Industrial Court.

Links

ABC News story

adam nicolai
 

Photo: Adam Nicolai source Border Watch

On the water

Commercial boat standards are for safety

Commercial boat standards are for safety


Murray Cod to be released in River Murray

Murray Cod to be released in River Murray


On the water archive

Videos

Paddle safe

An important summer boating message: wear your PFD to avoid an SOS

An important summer boating message: wear your PFD to avoid an SOS


Learn about boating safety at the Boat and Fishing Show

Learn about boating safety at the Boat and Fishing Show


Paddle safe archive

Scuttlebutt

Community meetings on fishing management options

Community meetings on fishing management options


Have your say on recreational fishing in SA

Have your say on recreational fishing in SA


Scuttlebutt archive